Fiber Optics
[Translate to English:] LWL-Reinigungsstifte
30
Sept
2026

Clean After Just One Click? What Comparative Tests of Fiber Optic Cleaning Pens Reveal

One click, and the fiber optic connector is clean? It's not quite that simple. The condition of the fiber end face is an important quality factor in fiber optic connections. IEC 61300-3-35 therefore specifies requirements, procedures, and acceptance criteria for the visual inspection of optical fiber end faces. The focus includes contamination, scratches, and other defects.

For installation, testing, and maintenance, this raises a practical question: How reliably does a cleaning pen work, and is a single cleaning cycle sufficient?

Comparative tests conducted by NTT Advanced Technology Corporation (NTT-AT) provide valuable insights under defined test conditions.

NEOCLEAN-F12 and F25: Which Cleaning Pen Is Right for You?

NetPeppers distributes the NEOCLEAN-F12/NP-FIBER21 and NEOCLEAN-F25/NP-FIBER11 fiber optic cleaning pens from NTT-AT for a range of commonly used fiber optic connectors.

The F12 is designed for MU and LC connectors, while the F25 is intended for SC, FC, ST, and E2000 connectors. Both models are suitable for UPC and APC systems.

NTT-AT uses a high-performance cleaning yarn in NEOCLEAN-F to remove grease and dust. The housing is made of antistatic material designed to reduce the reaccumulation of dust caused by static electricity. When not in use, the attachment can be secured to the rear end of the cleaner, while the connecting cord can be used as a wrist strap.

NEOCLEAN-F can also be used on transceiver ports. According to NTT-AT, it is suitable for both stub-based and lens-based interfaces. No damage to the lens was observed. However, no cleaning effect can be expected with lens-based interfaces.

What Does the Performance Comparison Show?

NTT-AT compared NEOCLEAN-F with two competing products under defined test conditions. According to NTT-AT, the cleaning test included 20 samples using LC connectors, both plugs and adapters. A VIAVI FBP-P5000i FiberChek Pro was used for inspection. The stringent evaluation criteria of IEC 61300-3-35, Edition 2.0, were applied as the pass/fail criteria.

The results were reported separately for LC adapters and LC plugs.
 

For LC adapters, NEOCLEAN-F and competing product B each achieved a pass rate of 100%, while competing product A achieved 95%. For LC plugs, the pass rates were 90% for NEOCLEAN-F, 80% for competing product A, and 75% for competing product B.

Under the tested conditions, NEOCLEAN-F therefore achieved the highest pass rate for the LC plugs tested.

It's Not Just About the Number of Clicks

The products also differ in their specified cleaning capacity. NTT-AT states that NEOCLEAN-F provides more than 1,000 cleaning cycles. The two competing products included in the comparison are rated for at least 500 and at least 775 cleaning cycles, respectively.

However, maximum cleaning capacity alone does not determine cleaning performance. Another important factor is the number of cleaning cycles required to achieve the desired inspection result.

What Do the MPO Comparisons Show?

Further tests conducted by NTT-AT with MPO cleaners demonstrate that the number of cleaning cycles required can vary significantly. However, these tests involved NEOCLEAN-M rather than NEOCLEAN-F12/NP-FIBER21 or F25/NP-FIBER11. The results are therefore not directly transferable.

In a test involving unpinned MPO12/APC connectors contaminated with artificial skin oil, NEOCLEAN-M achieved a per-fiber pass rate of 95.9% after one cleaning cycle, compared with 57.2% for the competing pen-type cleaner. After three cleaning cycles, the respective pass rates were 99.7% and 95.9%.

In another comparison, NTT-AT reported that the competing product tested required an average of approximately 4.5 cleaning cycles to achieve a per-fiber pass rate comparable to that of NEOCLEAN-M after a single cleaning cycle.

The MPO results therefore highlight one key point: In addition to maximum cleaning capacity, the actual number of cleaning cycles required can be an important evaluation criterion.

Putting the Comparative Tests into Perspective

The comparative tests were conducted by NTT-AT, the manufacturer of the NEOCLEAN products. The company points out that the results were obtained under specific test conditions and may differ in other applications. The results should therefore be regarded as documented comparative data obtained under the respective test conditions.

What Does This Mean in Practice?

For installation, testing, and maintenance, a clear procedure is recommended:

  1. Inspect the fiber end face: Check for contamination and defects before making the connection.
  2. Use the appropriate cleaner: Select a cleaning pen suitable for the connector type, ferrule geometry, and polish type, and use it correctly.
  3. Inspect again: After cleaning, verify that the end face meets the specified acceptance criteria.
  4. Establish the connection and test if required: If optical performance parameters such as insertion loss or return loss need to be verified, these must be measured separately.

What Matters Is the Result After the Click

The comparative tests show that cleaning pens can differ in their cleaning performance under defined test conditions. In practice, therefore, it is not just the number of possible cleaning cycles that matters. What is essential is that the cleaner is suitable for the connector type and reliably cleans the fiber end face.

The results apply to the specific test conditions investigated and cannot be directly generalized to other applications. Nevertheless, they provide documented evidence of the cleaning performance of the NEOCLEAN systems tested. In the LC comparison, NEOCLEAN-F achieved the highest pass rate for plugs among the three systems evaluated.

For installers, this means selecting the appropriate cleaner, cleaning the connector correctly, and inspecting the result afterwards. This helps reduce contamination as a preventable source of errors and establishes an important prerequisite for reliable fiber optic connections.

Any Questions?

We look forward to help you!

 

I agree that NetPeppers GmbH may contact me (by telephone or e-mail) and store the data I have provided for this purpose. The Privacy Policy I have thereby taken note of.